about
Alisa. 37. New Hampshire. Married for almost three years to this wonderful, funny, smart guy. Previously married. Went through in-vitro fertilization to have my five year old magical son Keegan. Stepmother to the charming Isabelle (6). Gushingly in love with our baby boy Harper(1). Policy Wonk and dreaded bureaucrat. Lover of fine cuisine, honeybees, truly romantic moments and the underdog.
cooking
Curried Beef Short Ribs

Note: I found this was more realistically four servings.

Finishing this dish with lime zest and juice brightens its rich flavors.

Yield 6 servings (serving size: about 3 ounces ribs, 2/3 cup rice, and about 2 1/2 tablespoons sauce)

2 teaspoons canola oil
2 pounds ...continue reading

view all my recipes

navigate
blogroll
archives
categories
Design by emtwo

« Blisters | Main | Blue Thumbs »

50 Pills

Another ride on the confidence rollercoaster. I was nervous until I got to class. Professors were friendly, funny and interesting. Up. Then we introduced ourselves. Down. I am not exaggerating when I say that of the 33 students all but five of them are doctors. So it's a PhD student, three law degrees concurrent with MPH students and me. Down. We get into an ethical question. The class is actively participating and I actually have the guts to speak. Up. The professor says that what is say is true and a good point. Up. Up. We get into the next ethical question. I am one of few who selects option A. Down. I am asked to explain my answer. Down. We finish the discussion and it is clear that answer A is wrong. Down. Down. I kick myself for not shutting up while I am ahead. I imagine that everyone is wondering how I got into the class. Down.
And really many people said things that were disputed and I certainly didn't stand out as wrong but that is not how it feels at the time. On the positive side, I have the whole getting there, parking and walking to class thing down. And I don't mind the crappy go and then slam on the brakes drivers that make Boston famous because I know it is only for a month. Keegan is with Tom tonight so I took my time going home, stopped by the grocery store and did chores. Now it's read, shower and bed. I'm boring already.

The first ethical dilemma:

You are chief of a ward with 100 patients. 50 of these patients need 2 pills to survive. One pill does not help them. 50 of these patients need 1 pill to survive. You have 50 pills. You can’t get more. Who should get the pills? On what basis should they be chosen?

TrackBack for this entry:
http://www.fillorburst.com/mt-tb.cgi/1139
Comments

you're not boring, you're brilliant!

Shared by sarah at July 6, 2006 9:58 PM

You're a superstar and you know it.

As for the ethical dilemma, this one is easy. You're supposed to be tempted to just easily give the pills to the 50 1-pill patients but that's not fair to the 2-pill patients - like they're penalized for having to take 2 pills.

The answer is easy: Humans didn't invent Rock-Paper-Scissors or Drawing Straws just for fun. The patients play a per pill choosing game that lets luck decide. Each 2-pill patient goes in a best of 7 series against a random pairing of 1-pill patients.

Shared by Beverly Baumgartner at July 6, 2006 10:12 PM

wow, that close sounds interesting. give yourself a break; it was only the first one. I'm not gonna even try. my brain is fried (its 5:30 pm)

Shared by Becki at July 7, 2006 5:26 PM

One of the many reasons why my PhD is on hold. I am lazy. I am tired. I don't want to feel like everyone is smarter than me when that is clearly not the case. You got in right? Kick some butt. Everyone has a voice and everyone learns from one another. Make the stuff upidity ups think outside of their box!

Now I should take my own advice! LOL

Shared by Bari at July 9, 2006 9:26 AM

that all sounds scary but you made it through!! :) I'm proud of ya!

Shared by mel at July 10, 2006 10:29 AM









Remember personal info?